As Amy and Sabrina grow closer, Karma looks for proof that Sabrina is bad news. Liam tries to set up Lauren, while Shane seeks advice.

As the new year approaches, Karma takes drastic measures to make Amy happy; Lauren is insecure when someone from her past reappears.

Amy and Lauren’s plan to reunite their parents is derailed by a revelation in Karma’s home life. Liam and Shane have dinner with Liam’s Rabbi.

Lauren’s quest to save Christmas at Hester puts Amy in a difficult position. Karma helps Felix get ready to ask out Amy, and Shane learns a secret about Noah.

Amy and Karma are both ready to make amends, but neither wants to be the first one to extend the olive branch; Zita shows her support for Liam.

Trying not to think about Karma, Amy decides to do a documentary about Lauren. Karma and Shane decide to start a band.

Karma and Shane try to one up each other; Amy is surprised by new feelings.

Hester’s future lies in the balance; Amy makes an important decision.

Amy and Karma argue; Liam receives some promising news about his future; Lauren makes a discovery about her relationship; Shane crosses a line to get what he wants.

When a new Principal cracks down on Hester, Shane leads a revolt. Amy suspects Karma is hiding something.

Lauren and Amy think one of their parents is having an affair. Karma and Shane feel insecure in their relationships.

Amy and Karma pretend to be a couple one more time; Shane and Liam try to find their groove again.

After Lauren enters a beauty pageant, Amy follows suit to prove she is a contender.

Karma deals with the fallout from Amy’s confession; Amy feels guilty about her tryst with Liam; Lauren and Shane devise a plan to protect Lauren’s secret.

Amy plans a scavenger hunt to celebrate Karma’s sixteenth birthday.

Karma hides her relationship with Liam while Amy hides her feelings from Karma.

Best friends Karma and Amy are mistaken for lesbians and decide to keep up the ruse when they’re nominated for Homecoming Queens.

Lauren threatens to out Amy to her conservative mother as Hester High gets ready for their first-ever same-sex Homecoming Dance.

Farrah’s bridal shower interrupts Amy and Karma’s plans.